Presentation, care, and outcomes of patients with NSTEMI according to World Bank country income classification: the ACVC-EAPCI EORP NSTEMI Registry of the European Society of Cardiology

European Heart Journal - Quality of Care and Clinical Outcomes

3 February 2023
Organised by: Logo
ESC Journals

Abstract

AbstractBackground

The majority of NSTEMI burden resides outside high-income countries (HICs). We describe presentation, care, and outcomes of NSTEMI by country income classification.

Methods and results

Prospective cohort study including 2947 patients with NSTEMI from 287 centres in 59 countries, stratified by World Bank country income classification. Quality of care was evaluated based on 12 guideline-recommended care interventions. The all-or-none scoring composite performance measure was used to define receipt of optimal care. Outcomes included in-hospital acute heart failure, stroke/transient ischaemic attack, and death, and 30-day mortality. Patients admitted with NSTEMI in low to lower-middle-income countries (LLMICs), compared with patients in HICs, were younger, more commonly diabetic, and current smokers, but with a lower burden of other comorbidities, and 76.7% met very high risk criteria for an immediate invasive strategy. Invasive coronary angiography use increased with ascending income classification (LLMICs, 79.2%; upper middle income countries [UMICs], 83.7%; HICs, 91.0%), but overall care quality did not (≥80% of eligible interventions achieved: LLMICS, 64.8%; UMICs 69.6%; HICs 55.1%). Rates of acute heart failure (LLMICS, 21.3%; UMICs, 12.1%; HICs, 6.8%; P < 0.001), stroke/transient ischaemic attack (LLMICS: 2.5%; UMICs: 1.5%; HICs: 0.9%; P = 0.04), in-hospital mortality (LLMICS, 3.6%; UMICs: 2.8%; HICs: 1.0%; P < 0.001) and 30-day mortality (LLMICs, 4.9%; UMICs, 3.9%; HICs, 1.5%; P < 0.001) exhibited an inverse economic gradient.

Conclusion

Patients with NSTEMI in LLMICs present with fewer comorbidities but a more advanced stage of acute disease, and have worse outcomes compared with HICs. A cardiovascular health narrative is needed to address this inequity across economic boundaries.

Contributors

M Cigut
M Cigut

Author

Ramesh Nadarajah
Ramesh Nadarajah

Author

Leeds General Infirmary Leeds , United Kingdom of Great Britain & Northern Ireland

T Furlan
T Furlan

Author

V Grilj
V Grilj

Author

M Rezun
M Rezun

Author

K Shokry
K Shokry

Author

Yolande Appelman
Yolande Appelman

Author

Amsterdam University Medical Centre (AUMC) Amsterdam , Netherlands (The)

A Imam
A Imam

Author

B Hafez
B Hafez

Author

A Zahran
A Zahran

Author

Andrzej Budaj
Andrzej Budaj

Author

Grochowski Hospital, Centre of Postgraduate Medical Education Warsaw , Poland

Hector Bueno
Hector Bueno

Author

National Centre for Cardiovascular Research (CNIC) Madrid , Spain

F Lopez
F Lopez

Author

Maddalena Lettino
Maddalena Lettino

Author

IRCCS San Gerardo of Tintori Foundation Monza , Italy

A Samir
A Samir

Author

A Budaj
A Budaj

Author

N Dagres
N Dagres

Author

A Kamal
A Kamal

Author

P Jordan
P Jordan

Author

S Sallam
S Sallam

Author

C P Gale
C P Gale

Author

L Mila
L Mila

Author

A Ali
A Ali

Author

A Sionis
A Sionis

Author

A Saad
A Saad

Author

M Ali
M Ali

Author

B Iung
B Iung

Author

S James
S James

Author

K V Nagy
K V Nagy

Author

G Parati
G Parati

Author

C Simon
C Simon

Author

O Alegre
O Alegre

Author

M Alsina
M Alsina

Author

R Lubi
R Lubi

Author

T Uuetoa
T Uuetoa

Author

U Zeymer
U Zeymer

Author

C P Gale
C P Gale

Author

A Budaj
A Budaj

Author

N Dagres
N Dagres

Author

U Kiitam
U Kiitam

Author

X Bosch
X Bosch

Author

C Durier
C Durier

Author

P Vidal
P Vidal

Author

A Gray
A Gray

Author

F Marin
F Marin

Author

K V Nagy
K V Nagy

Author

U Zeymer
U Zeymer

Author

L Silva
L Silva

Author

A Blasco
A Blasco

Author

D Adlam
D Adlam

Author

A Fofana
A Fofana

Author

J Ortega
J Ortega

Author

M Dweck
M Dweck

Author

L Bahon
L Bahon

Author

F Good
F Good

Author

T Casado
T Casado

Author

F Prieur
F Prieur

Author

B Iung
B Iung

Author

P Ludman
P Ludman

Author

L Lund
L Lund

Author

H Bueno
H Bueno

Author

N Roy
N Roy

Author

R Martin
R Martin

Author

T Perret
T Perret

Author

B Meder
B Meder

Author

R Maruri
R Maruri

Author

S Ranc
S Ranc

Author

K V Nagy
K V Nagy

Author

G Moreno
G Moreno

Author

C Moris
C Moris

Author

S Rio
S Rio

Author

A Ayesta
A Ayesta

Author

D Neglia
D Neglia

Author

G Bonnet
G Bonnet

Author

J Romero
J Romero

Author

P Deharo
P Deharo

Author

Maddalena Lettino
Maddalena Lettino

Author

IRCCS San Gerardo of Tintori Foundation Monza , Italy

Hector Bueno
Hector Bueno

Author

National Centre for Cardiovascular Research (CNIC) Madrid , Spain

Andrzej Budaj
Andrzej Budaj

Author

Grochowski Hospital, Centre of Postgraduate Medical Education Warsaw , Poland

G Yanes
G Yanes

Author

V Decalf
V Decalf

Author

A Hakme
A Hakme

Author

P Jorge
P Jorge

Author

Y Biron
Y Biron

Author

A Lucon
A Lucon

Author

P Hery
P Hery

Author

F Digne
F Digne

Author

F Huchet
F Huchet

Author

G Bonet
G Bonet

Author

A Humida
A Humida

Author

G Quaino
G Quaino

Author

E Hamid
E Hamid

Author

T Ali
T Ali

Author

Y Ali
Y Ali

Author

M Ali
M Ali

Author

B Farah
B Farah

Author

B Honton
B Honton

Author

M Badri
M Badri

Author

M Cottin
M Cottin

Author

F Petit
F Petit

Author

J Varlot
J Varlot

Author

A Abdin
A Abdin

Author

C Hamm
C Hamm

Author

M Haas
M Haas

Author

C Hamm
C Hamm

Author

L Abid
L Abid

Author

K Maier
K Maier

Author

M Oksul
M Oksul

Author

V Novas
V Novas

Author

C Dumont
C Dumont

Author

A Akgun
A Akgun

Author

H Ari
H Ari

Author

S Ari
S Ari

Author

V Can
V Can

Author

B Tuncay
B Tuncay

Author

G Tzanis
G Tzanis

Author

V Tzifos
V Tzifos

Author

A Milkas
A Milkas

Author

H Kaya
H Kaya

Author

V Hoyle
V Hoyle

Author

L Dursun
L Dursun

Author

V Tapia
V Tapia

Author

O Tasar
O Tasar

Author

S Kilic
S Kilic

Author

O Baydar
O Baydar

Author

A Kilic
A Kilic

Author

B Gungor
B Gungor

Author

K Huber
K Huber

Author

G Zeren
G Zeren

Author

A Ahmed
A Ahmed

Author

M Erturk
M Erturk

Author

M Derntl
M Derntl

Author

M Hasun
M Hasun

Author

C Can
C Can

Author

B Yagmur
B Yagmur

Author

S Oney
S Oney

Author

M M Haq
M M Haq

Author

M Ziyrek
M Ziyrek

Author

T Sen
T Sen

Author

M G Azam
M G Azam

Author

O Utku
O Utku

Author

J Jahan
J Jahan

Author

A Celik
A Celik

Author

C Goudis
C Goudis

Author

S Daios
S Daios

Author

P Koukis
P Koukis

Author

S Aerts
S Aerts

Author

F Besli
F Besli

Author

C Mondo
C Mondo

Author

T Semu
T Semu

Author

J S Atos
J S Atos

Author

I Wajid
I Wajid

Author

Z Ruzsa
Z Ruzsa

Author

V Somers
V Somers

Author

D Becker
D Becker

Author

K Bakr
K Bakr

Author

R Garrod
R Garrod

Author

F Makia
F Makia

Author

F Eldeeb
F Eldeeb

Author

A Gomaa
A Gomaa

Author

M Buysse
M Buysse

Author

G Nakad
G Nakad

Author

R Nair
R Nair

Author

P Mota
P Mota

Author

R Shetty
R Shetty

Author

P Prior
P Prior

Author

C Bs
C Bs

Author

S G
S G

Author

R S
R S

Author

J Rand
J Rand

Author

A Sinha
A Sinha

Author

E Hoffer
E Hoffer

Author

A Kumar
A Kumar

Author

M Clark
M Clark

Author

A Kumar
A Kumar

Author

R Raj
R Raj

Author

M Massoz
M Massoz

Author

S Dharma
S Dharma

Author

V Turner
V Turner

Author

P Evrard
P Evrard

Author

A Crew
A Crew

Author

S Hope
S Hope

Author

J Howson
J Howson

Author

S Jones
S Jones

Author

Z Dakhil
Z Dakhil

Author

D Mayne
D Mayne

Author

S Amen
S Amen

Author

G Wray
G Wray

Author

B Rasool
B Rasool

Author

A Rajeeb
A Rajeeb

Author

K Amber
K Amber

Author

C Hanet
C Hanet

Author

E Begic
E Begic

Author

S Regan
S Regan

Author

R Watkin
R Watkin

Author

A Dozic
A Dozic

Author

E Hrvat
E Hrvat

Author

D Mackic
D Mackic

Author

P Ludman
P Ludman

Author

A Subo
A Subo

Author

K Hutton
K Hutton

Author

A Dzubur
A Dzubur

Author

D Rebic
D Rebic

Author

F Noori
F Noori

Author

M Kyavar
M Kyavar

Author

S Garg
S Garg

Author

E Hodzic
E Hodzic

Author

M Hujdur
M Hujdur

Author

R Singh
R Singh

Author

E Musija
E Musija

Author

K Davies
K Davies

Author

L Brigic
L Brigic

Author

H Desai
H Desai

Author

M Cibo
M Cibo

Author

N Iqbal
N Iqbal

Author

A Begic
A Begic

Author

A Iglica
A Iglica

Author

S Chalil
S Chalil

Author

N Resic
N Resic

Author

O Assaf
O Assaf

Author

Y Jenab
Y Jenab

Author

A Biria
A Biria

Author

L Benham
L Benham

Author

J Brown
J Brown

Author

K Orvin
K Orvin

Author

A Eisen
A Eisen

Author

J Glen
J Glen

Author

M Sut
M Sut

Author

R Vizel
R Vizel

Author

H Kfir
H Kfir

Author

A Uttley
A Uttley

Author

N Akhtar
N Akhtar

Author

D Gobic
D Gobic

Author

D Lulic
D Lulic

Author

G Bacic
G Bacic

Author

M Vinod
M Vinod

Author

A Wilson
A Wilson

Author

A Curcio
A Curcio

Author

N Bowers
N Bowers

Author

S Harvey
S Harvey

Author

M Marino
M Marino

Author

L Groch
L Groch

Author

S Sharma
S Sharma

Author

M Rezek
M Rezek

Author

L Meloni
L Meloni

Author

J Law
J Law

Author

J Sitar
J Sitar

Author

E Young
E Young

Author

A Hoye
A Hoye

Author

P Harper
P Harper

Author

K Rowe
K Rowe

Author

M Biddau
M Biddau

Author

E Garau
E Garau

Author

M Been
M Been

Author

L Pesl
L Pesl

Author

E French
E French

Author

C Gibson
C Gibson

Author

F Tousek
F Tousek

Author

S Hobson
S Hobson

Author

A Kay
A Kay

Author

I Ghaly
I Ghaly

Author

S Habiba
S Habiba

Author

A Habib
A Habib

Author

G Casu
G Casu

Author

G Novo
G Novo

Author

M Kent
M Kent

Author

H Bahaa
H Bahaa

Author

A Samir
A Samir

Author

M Adel
M Adel

Author

S Evola
S Evola

Author

S Clark
S Clark

Author

L Duncan
L Duncan

Author

I Wanda
I Wanda

Author

P Read
P Read

Author

A Afsar
A Afsar

Author

V Rivers
V Rivers

Author

S Bell
S Bell

Author

G Peters
G Peters

Author

G Spica
G Spica

Author

D Pavan
D Pavan

Author

M Morgan
M Morgan

Author

B Taylor
B Taylor

Author

S Twiss
S Twiss

Author

M Black
M Black

Author

A Clark
A Clark

Author

E Sonego
E Sonego

Author

J Currie
J Currie

Author

C Gaudio
C Gaudio

Author

L George
L George

Author

C Mcgee
C Mcgee

Author

L Izzat
L Izzat

Author

T Lewis
T Lewis

Author

Z Omar
Z Omar

Author

N Bruno
N Bruno

Author

F Ahmed
F Ahmed

Author

S Mackie
S Mackie

Author

A Oommen
A Oommen

Author

S Aleti
S Aleti

Author

M Jose
M Jose

Author

A Peluso
A Peluso

Author

C Prota
C Prota

Author

I Radano
I Radano

Author

J Deery
J Deery

Author

A Knight
A Knight

Author

C Price
C Price

Author

S Turney
S Turney

Author

A Kardos
A Kardos

Author

L Wren
L Wren

Author

G Bega
G Bega

Author

M Merlo
M Merlo

Author

A Perkan
A Perkan

Author

F Ramani
F Ramani

Author

E Fabris
E Fabris

Author

K Cullen
K Cullen

Author

L Checco
L Checco

Author

S Frea
S Frea

Author

K Sugi
K Sugi

Author

S Jones
S Jones

Author

T Kitai
T Kitai

Author

E Kirkup
E Kirkup

Author

B Amirov
B Amirov

Author

A Mcleod
A Mcleod

Author

J Burton
J Burton

Author

R King
R King

Author

J Quinn
J Quinn

Author

S Munt
S Munt

Author

J Porter
J Porter

Author

K Leng
K Leng

Author

N Temple
N Temple

Author

K Wells
K Wells

Author

A Taneja
A Taneja

Author

E Cann
E Cann

Author

A Erglis
A Erglis

Author

B Hyams
B Hyams

Author

E Jones
E Jones

Author

F Reed
F Reed

Author

J Smith
J Smith

Author

A Turner
A Turner

Author

T Ward
T Ward

Author

A Whyte
A Whyte

Author

S Smith
S Smith

Author

V Murray
V Murray

Author

R Walker
R Walker

Author

C Weston
C Weston

Author

C Brown
C Brown

Author

K Curtis
K Curtis

Author

K Dixon
K Dixon

Author

T Wells
T Wells

Author

F Trim
F Trim

Author

J Ghosh
J Ghosh

Author

M Mavuri
M Mavuri

Author

L Barman
L Barman

Author

T Neale
T Neale

Author

J Smith
J Smith

Author

J Toohie
J Toohie

Author

E Parker
E Parker

Author

J Hill
J Hill

Author

M Hood
M Hood

Author

J Barker
J Barker

Author

H Denney
H Denney

Author

E Camus
E Camus

Author

J Middle
J Middle

Author

S Gati
S Gati

Author

P Kirk
P Kirk

Author

M Lynch
M Lynch

Author

E Pllaha
E Pllaha

Author

S Xuereb
S Xuereb

Author

V Ivanov
V Ivanov

Author

P Baker
P Baker

Author

C Cruz
C Cruz

Author

K Lamb
K Lamb

Author

A Price
A Price

Author

M Mamas
M Mamas

Author

I Massey
I Massey

Author

M Abras
M Abras

Author

J Wain
J Wain

Author

S Junejo
S Junejo

Author

S Fuior
S Fuior

Author

M Ivanov
M Ivanov

Author

T Danila
T Danila

Author

L Grib
L Grib

Author

K Martin
K Martin

Author

D Obaid
D Obaid

Author

M Tasnic
M Tasnic

Author

C Cozma
C Cozma

Author

G Sorici
G Sorici

Author

M Dagva
M Dagva

Author

C Davies
C Davies

Author

D Evans
D Evans

Author

E Dandar
E Dandar

Author

C Thomas
C Thomas

Author

M Dayer
M Dayer

Author

H Mills
H Mills

Author

N Greig
N Greig

Author

S Kundu
S Kundu

Author

L Tonks
L Tonks

Author

M Beekes
M Beekes

Author

V Houben
V Houben

Author

H Button
H Button

Author

W Bor
W Bor

Author

C Amadi
C Amadi

Author

U Sheikh
U Sheikh

Author

A Yonis
A Yonis

Author

D Hughes
D Hughes

Author

S Tupare
S Tupare

Author

J Sutton
J Sutton

Author

M Dejan
M Dejan

Author

P Rogers
P Rogers

Author

P Batin
P Batin

Author

D Conway
D Conway

Author

S Kocho
S Kocho

Author

D Exley
D Exley

Author

J Wright
J Wright

Author

T Nageh
T Nageh

Author

O Kalpak
O Kalpak

Author

B Hadebe
B Hadebe

Author

H Pejkov
H Pejkov

Author

E Grueva
E Grueva

Author

H Hamdan
H Hamdan

Author

J Cooper
J Cooper

Author

C Dandy
C Dandy

Author

M Tutic
M Tutic

Author

T Taylor
T Taylor

Author

S Ahmed
S Ahmed

Author

J Azam
J Azam

Author

O Faheem
O Faheem

Author

C Hayes
C Hayes

Author

N Qamar
N Qamar

Author

S Furnaz
S Furnaz

Author

Y Mcgill
Y Mcgill

Author

K Kazmi
K Kazmi

Author

T Saghir
T Saghir

Author

A Aneel
A Aneel

Author

A Asim
A Asim

Author

F Madiha
F Madiha

Author

A Alyavi
A Alyavi

Author

B Alyavi
B Alyavi

Author

J Uzokov
J Uzokov

Author

M Kosiak
M Kosiak

Author

A Wester
A Wester

Author

K Wiklo
K Wiklo

Author

J Sacha
J Sacha

Author

R Ryczek
R Ryczek

Author

M Roik
M Roik

Author

A Labyk
A Labyk

Author

M Potepa
M Potepa

Author

A Budaj
A Budaj

Author

A Torun
A Torun

Author

A Fojt
A Fojt

Author

Z Huczek
Z Huczek

Author

K Brust
K Brust

Author

M Gasior
M Gasior

Author

M Santos
M Santos

Author

D Faria
D Faria

Author

P Magno
P Magno

Author

M Nédio
M Nédio

Author

C Sousa
C Sousa

Author

H Santos
H Santos

Author

M Carias
M Carias

Author

J Pais
J Pais

Author

J Mimoso
J Mimoso

Author

J Guedes
J Guedes

Author

T Mota
T Mota

Author

M Mendes
M Mendes

Author

C Strong
C Strong

Author

G Pais
G Pais

Author

T Mano
T Mano

Author

J Reis
J Reis

Author

M Selas
M Selas

Author

P Pinto
P Pinto

Author

L Reis
L Reis

Author

I Cruz
I Cruz

Author

S Torres
S Torres

Author

A Luz
A Luz

Author

R Costa
R Costa

Author

A Frias
A Frias

Author

C Coelho
C Coelho

Author

N Cotrim
N Cotrim

Author

R Duarte
R Duarte

Author

R Gomes
R Gomes

Author

F Matias
F Matias

Author

J Neiva
J Neiva

Author

D Caeiro
D Caeiro

Author

G Silva
G Silva

Author

S Mercea
S Mercea

Author

G-A Dan
G-A Dan

Author

A-R Dan
A-R Dan

Author

C Adam
C Adam

Author

D Pop
D Pop

Author

I Donoiu
I Donoiu

Author

M Grecu
M Grecu

Author

A Cozma
A Cozma

Author

M Rus
M Rus

Author

R Larisa
R Larisa

Author

M Moisi
M Moisi

Author

E Ban
E Ban

Author

A Buzle
A Buzle

Author

S Lupu
S Lupu

Author

A Mitre
A Mitre

Author

R Rudzik
R Rudzik

Author

I Sus
I Sus

Author

D Opris
D Opris

Author

C Mornos
C Mornos

Author

A Betiu
A Betiu

Author

O Ioan
O Ioan

Author

C Luca
C Luca

Author

C Roman
C Roman

Author

D Brie
D Brie

Author

S Crisan
S Crisan

Author

D Gaita
D Gaita

Author

E Zubova
E Zubova

Author

V Larina
V Larina

Author

I Meray
I Meray

Author

L Goreva
L Goreva

Author

F Ageev
F Ageev

Author

V Ryabov
V Ryabov

Author

V Budyak
V Budyak

Author

H Khalaf
H Khalaf

Author

W Kamal
W Kamal

Author

A Ahmed
A Ahmed

Author

N Attia
N Attia

Author

D Matic
D Matic

Author

L Savic
L Savic

Author

N Zlatic
N Zlatic

Author

O Vesic
O Vesic

Author

R Vucic
R Vucic

Author

T Kostic
T Kostic

Author

V Mitic
V Mitic

Author

T Pantic
T Pantic

Author

L Pupic
L Pupic

Author

P H Loh
P H Loh

Author

W Kong
W Kong

Author

K-K Poh
K-K Poh

Author

C-H Sia
C-H Sia

Author

K Saw
K Saw

Author

D Liška
D Liška

Author

M Gbur
M Gbur

Author

R Maxian
R Maxian

Author

T Keric
T Keric

Author

G Kotnik
G Kotnik

Author

M Cercek
M Cercek

Author

I Djokic
I Djokic

Author

L Lipar
L Lipar

Author

D Crncic
D Crncic

Author

M Tibaut
M Tibaut

Author