In order to bring you the best possible user experience, this site uses Javascript. If you are seeing this message, it is likely that the Javascript option in your browser is disabled. For optimal viewing of this site, please ensure that Javascript is enabled for your browser.

Member Benefit

This content is only available year-round to ESC Professional Members, Fellows of the ESC, and Young Combined Members

Seeing is believing: the feasibility and acceptability of using wearable cameras to enhance self-management of heart failure.

Session Nursing and Allied Health Professions Investigator Award

Speaker Doctor Susie Cartledge

Event : ESC Congress 2019

  • Topic : cardiovascular nursing and allied professions
  • Sub-topic : Chronic Nursing Care
  • Session type : Special Session

Authors : S Cartledge (Melbourne,AU), M Rogerson (Melbourne,AU), TKR Singh (Melbourne,AU), V Huynh Huu (Geelong,AU), D Phung (Geelong,AU), C Gurrin (Dublin,IE), C Neil (Melbourne,AU), K Ball (Melbourne,AU), R Maddison (Melbourne,AU)

S. Cartledge1 , M. Rogerson1 , T.K.R. Singh1 , V. Huynh Huu2 , D. Phung2 , C. Gurrin3 , C. Neil4 , K. Ball1 , R. Maddison1 , 1Deakin University, Institute for Physical Activity and Nutrition - Melbourne - Australia , 2Deakin University, Department of Pattern Recogntion & Data Analytics - Geelong - Australia , 3Dublin City University (DCU), School of Computing - Dublin - Ireland , 4Western Health - Melbourne - Australia ,

On behalf: Digital health for lifestyle and disease management

Chronic Nursing Care

European Heart Journal ( 2019 ) 40 ( Supplement ), 96

Introduction: For people with heart failure (HF), self-management (e.g., adhering to prescribed medication, management of fluid restrictions and daily weighing) and dietary management is critical for disease management. The rise of technologies (mobile phones, wearable cameras) for healthcare use offers potential support for people to better manage their disease. We aimed to test the feasibility and utility of wearable cameras for identifying self-management practices and to determine if these images can be used to enhance self-management in people with HF.

Methods: Participants wore the “narrative clip”, a small wearable camera for one month during waking hours; still images were taken every 30 seconds. Using state-of-the-art artificial intelligence techniques, we investigated automated image analysis of daily life activities to determine the potential of these systems to identify four categories of human activities: medication management, dietary intake, meal preparation and physical activity. Participants also completed a semi-structured questionnaire about acceptability and feasibility.

Results: 30 participants (mean age 73.6 years, 60% male) with HF NYHA Class II-III were recruited. A total of 629,603 images were available for analysis. Higher order analyses were conducted to determine precision of identifying correct images for the pre-defined self-management categories. Precision of identifying the correct images was highest in dietary intake (average 49%, range 13–94%) followed by meal preparation (average 40%, range 1–99%) and physical activity (average 31%, range 0–95%). Medication management had the lowest precision (average 6%, range 6–22%). Manual review of images revealed substantial periods of sedentary time, typically paired with screen time (watching television, playing cards on a computer). All participants agreed the camera was easy to use and felt they had privacy when using the camera. The majority of participants felt comfortable wearing the camera (93%) and thought this technique will help people with HF in the future (93%).

Conclusions: Images from wearable cameras provided rich contextual data to better understand the lived experiences of people with HF and the device was acceptable to participants. Automated machine learning tools require more annotated data for training to enhance precision, which will be achieved via further annotation, fine-tuning and retraining the data analysis model. Despite these challenges, the data collected can be used as an adjunct to traditional data collection methods such as self-report. Once data analysis techniques are refined, objective data from wearable cameras may also prove useful for nurses to provide tailored education for self-management.

Get your access to resources

Join now
  • 1ESC Professional Members – access all ESC Congress resources 
  • 2ESC Association Members (Ivory, Silver, Gold) – access your Association’s resources
  • 3Under 40 or in training - with a Combined Membership, access all resources
Join now
logo esc

Our mission: To reduce the burden of cardiovascular disease

Who we are