In order to bring you the best possible user experience, this site uses Javascript. If you are seeing this message, it is likely that the Javascript option in your browser is disabled. For optimal viewing of this site, please ensure that Javascript is enabled for your browser.

The free consultation period for this content is over.

It is now only available year-round to ESC Professional Members, Fellows of the ESC, and Young combined Members

Improving the value of clinical variables in the assessment of cardiovascular risk using Artificial Neural Networks

Session Cardiovascular risk prediction models: for improvement?

Speaker Luis Eduardo Juarez-Orozco

Event : ESC Congress 2017

  • Topic : preventive cardiology
  • Sub-topic : Risk Factors and Prevention – Cardiovascular Risk Assessment
  • Session type : Moderated Posters

Authors : L E Juarez-Orozco (Turku,FI), RJJ Knol (Alkmaar,NL), CA Sanchez-Catasus (Groningen,NL), FM Van Der Zant (Alkmaar,NL), J Knuuti (Turku,FI)

L.E. Juarez-Orozco1 , R.J.J. Knol2 , C.A. Sanchez-Catasus3 , F.M. Van Der Zant2 , J. Knuuti1 , 1Turku University Hospital, PET Center - Turku - Finland , 2Cardiac Imaging Division Alkmaar, Northwest Clinics, Department of Nuclear Medicine - Alkmaar - Netherlands , 3University Medical Center Groningen, Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging - Groningen - Netherlands ,

European Heart Journal ( 2017 ) 38 ( Supplement ), 227-228

Background: There is a substantial number of interrelated variables that have been associated to coronary artery disease (CAD) and to an increased risk of adverse cardiovascular outcomes. Currently, machine learning algorithms such as Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) constitute flexible models capable of characterizing complex relationships between numerous variables. ANN can be trained and applied to complex classification problems. On the other hand, PET perfusion imaging studies have demonstrated that a hampered myocardial perfusion reserve (MPR) (<2.0) conveys a significant risk for adverse cardiovascular outcomes. The present study generated and applied an ANN for the prediction of a PET-measured hampered MPR based on simple available predictors in patients with intermediate risk of CAD.

Methods: We included 1,241 patients with no previous MI or revascularization referred to 13N-ammonia PET for suspected ischemia. They were randomly divided into training, testing and holdout datasets (6:2:2). Demographic (sex, age, BMI and family history of CAD), clinical (chest complaints, diabetes, smoking, dyslipidemia, hypertension, rest heart rate [HR] and resting blood pressure [BP]) and complementary diagnostic data (Duke score, abnormal rest ECG, abnormal stress ECG, stress HR, % of max HR, stress BP, rest LVEF and stress LVEF) was retrieved. A multilayer perceptron analysis constructed the feed forward back propagation ANN with a hyperbolic tangent as the activating function. The network was trained and tested to classify the probability of cases of presenting a reduced MPR (<2.0). The ANN was then applied to the holdout dataset. The area under the curve (AUC) and normalised importance (NI) of the predictors were reported. Additionally, ensemble boosting of the ANN was performed to explore for accuracy improvement.

Results: The resulting ANN architecture used one hidden layer (with 6 nodes) and it showed a stable overall accuracy of 75% in the divided datasets, showing adequate generalisation. The ANN's AUC was 0.77 and the 5 most relevant predictors for network's construction were rest HR, age, stress, LVEF, BMI and stress HR (with a NI=100%, 63%, 41%, 32.5% and 31.3%). The ANN was generally more accurate when classifying a patient with a normal MPR than one with an abnormal MPR. Ensemble boosting, which iteratively created and improved the network classifiers achieved an increment of the overall accuracy to 84% when classifying new patients.

Conclusion: This study suggests that machine learning in the form of an ANN may be utilised to improve identification patients who will demonstrate a reduced MPR, based on simple and readily available clinical data, with a good overall accuracy (84%). This opens the possibility to improve the characterisation of patients at risk based on numerous and interrelated clinical variables. Further research into the application of ANNs with emerging and relevant predictors of cardiovascular risk is warranted.

The free consultation period for this content is over.

It is now only available year-round to ESC Professional Members, Fellows of the ESC, and Young combined Members

Members get more

Join now
  • 1ESC Professional Members – access all resources from general ESC events 
  • 2ESC Association Members (Ivory, Silver, Gold) – access your Association’s resources
  • 3Under 40 or in training - with a Combined Membership, access all resources
Join now

Our sponsors

ESC 365 is supported by Bayer, Boehringer Ingelheim and Lilly Alliance, Bristol-Myers Squibb and Pfizer Alliance, Novartis Pharma AG and Vifor Pharma in the form of educational grants. The sponsors were not involved in the development of this platform and had no influence on its content.

logo esc

Our mission: To reduce the burden of cardiovascular disease

Who we are